Bacaro – romantic, sexy, rustic, and hidden restaurant on an unassuming street in the Lower East Side. You really feel like you’re in on some sort of secret when you go down the stairs into Bacaro’s cellar. Apparently, the space used to be an aquarium so it has an underground, musty, dungeon-like feel to it. It is elegant with dark stones, old wood, candles, and secret caverns. Bacaro’s cellar is truly one of the most unique and beautiful dining spaces I’ve ever been to in NYC.
The wine list is diverse and affordable. We went with a very reasonably priced Pinot Noir from Alto Adige – delish.
The feast began with their crostini of the day – It came with 3 different spreads: Olive Tapenade, White Fish, and Mushroom. The white fish was definitely the best with big chunks of peppery, flaky, & fresh fish.
Next, we got the grilled asparagus with baked eggs and grana. Asparagus and eggs is one of my favorite combinations – the egg was runny and mixed perfectly with the creamy cheese.
We finished things off with 2 of their specials for the evening.
First, baked razor clams with breadcrumbs and a tomato, lemon, garlic sauce. The clams were large, dense, and slightly sweet. I actually would have drank the broth if I could have. These were my favorite part of the meal.
Last we had their black spaghetti with cuttlefish – in a slightly spicy, tangy, and light tomato sauce. Delicious sauce, al dente pasta, and large pieces of creamy cuttlefish. Delicious.
Overall, highly recommend for a unique and authentic Italian dining experience in a setting that is unlike any other you will find in Manhattan. It is a must try.